Are TV-sized displays actually practical as PC gaming monitors?

Date:
Tue, 31 Aug 2021 19:27:11 +0000

Description:
TVs have been pushing some exciting display features that typical gaming monitors just havent been keeping up with, but some larger options do exist. Is such a massive display really practical as a PC gaming monitor, though?

FULL STORY ======================================================================

In just the past few years, 4K TVs plowed through the market with a ton of features and technologies that made them almost irresistible. The best 4K TVs for gaming are offering high refresh rates and adaptive sync technologies to contend with gaming monitors , but the wide color gamuts and staggering peak brightness levels for HDR on these TVs put most gaming monitors to shame
even our favorite one, the LG UltraGear 38GN950 .

A select few gaming monitors borrow TV tech like 10-bit color depths and full-array local dimming to keep up, but these monitors are just as large as the TVs theyre competing with. And even smaller monitors do boast HDR specs
to compete with TVs, they often cost as much or more than those TVs. This leaves PC gamers who want the best visuals at their desk in a pickle: stick
to a smaller monitor without the latest TV tech, pay big-screen prices for a smaller monitor, or just go big. But, how practical is it really to use a TV-sized display as a PC gaming monitor? We decided to find out the hard way. (Image credit: Future) The setup

We didnt want to let a poor choice of panel or features skew the results of our experiment against the big display, so we picked up a 55-inch LG CX OLED TV to get one of the most compelling, large gaming screens on the market. The display offers a 120Hz variable refresh rate at 4K with a wide color gamut, high peak brightness, and a contrast ratio no gaming monitor can match. This left its size as the main variable as to how well it worked in our setup.

We mounted the LG CX on our 52-inch wide desk, of which it took up almost the entire width, but we still had space for a desk-size mouse pad for our mouse and keyboard in front of the display. Thatll be a warning flag for some not every desk is going to be able to hold such a large display.

Setting up a desk space with such a large display is also harder. Its not
easy reaching around to the back of such a big display to plug in HDMI cables or to route USB cables for peripherals. And, of course, hoisting the TV onto the desk can present its own difficulties. If youre regularly changing things around in your setup, a big screen just makes it harder.

With the TV in position, we were able to use our gaming PC either seated up close at the desk or we could roll our chair back and play at a distance. Since our focus here is how well a large display can serve in place of a gaming monitor and not for couch gaming, though, the ability to play at a distance is just a perk to note. (Image credit: LG) The experience

The presence of a 55-inch display on our desk was almost immediately overwhelming and took some getting used to. It effectively fills the majority of our field of view. A 34-inch ultrawide gaming monitor might seem fairly expansive, but it pales in comparison to the scale of a 55-inch TV sitting
the same distance from our eyes.

As a workspace, its almost magical. The ability to move windows to just about anywhere and fit plenty on the display at once cant be overlooked. But, we quickly found the drawbacks adding up.

4K is for farther away

For one thing, the much-praised 4K resolution that has become ubiquitous in TVs doesnt hold up so well from the usual viewing distance at a desk. To put things into perspective, a 55-inch 4K TV is akin four 27-inch 1080p monitors, which isnt the paramount of sharpness. At even arms length, we noticed individual pixels clearly enough. This would be less of an issue on a 48-inch display or 43-inch like Gigabytes Aorus FV43U. But even in the case of a 43-inch display, youre looking at a pixel density of 102 PPI that falls short of the 27-inch 1440p monitors that are almost a staple in PC gaming.

The ability to peep pixels on that granular level hurts the gaming experience some, too. Though having a lot of graphics in motion helps distract from each pixel, it still stands out when we stop to appreciate the fine details in games. If you hate seeing jagged edges because of weak anti-aliasing, you
wont stand for this.

Bright for our eyesight

While theres no knocking a wider color gamut, the high peak brightnesses of big screens is also a different experience up close. The LG CX isnt the brightest TV you can get, as OLEDs are more about contrast ratio where QLED TVs are doing more for peak brightness, but the display is still a lot brighter than the many VESA DisplayHDR 400 monitors popping up on the market. Despite not being the brightest, the LG CX can be a strain on our eyes, and
we even went as far as dialing down the brightness levels, which definitely helped with usability.

But, limiting the brightness may defeat the purpose for some. The main thing smaller PC monitors fall behind on (besides size, of course) is brightness just have a look at how few monitors below 43 inches earned the DisplayHDR 1000 certification . If the reason for buying a massive display for your PC gaming setup is so you can enjoy higher peak brightnesses but the actual brightness is so high you have to turn it down, is there actually a point in buying that bigger display?

Framing things differently

Its not all bad, though. We found some perks to the massive size of the display. Playing shooters, the area for scoped fire was so huge, it was incredibly easy to make out targets and keep them in the crosshairs. What might have been a 2X scope gave us the viability of a 4X scope. Similarly, distant details were easier to perceive. That said, the size of the display also meant some part of the scene would be out in our peripheral vision, making those bits harder to see in the heat of the moment.

Since our field of view was so full, the experience was almost like VR but the motion sickness-inducing kind. Running animations that bring a lot of camera movement were dizzying.

There are some options to tweak the display, though. If the full expanse of the display is useful in some games and a hindrance in others, you dont have to use the whole display. Its possible to output video at a different resolution and aspect ratio from the displays native specs, such as going for a 21:9 or 32:9 area. This could still take full advantage of the display
width without expanding so much into the vertical area, and it can be a lot cheaper than ultra-wide options like the Samsung Odyssey G9. It will result
in letterboxing, but on a premium display with a high contrast ratio or local dimming, those black bars may not be too distracting (or will be pure black, in the case of an OLED display like the LG CX). (Image credit: Future) Is it practical or worth it?

While it was an interesting experiment, the up-close-and-personal nature of gaming made a TV-size display feel more absurd than anything. For the few cases where it showed utility, it wasnt achieved practically. For example, setting up a bunch of windows to work on was still held back by the low sharpness and the reality that only one or two of them would be anywhere
close to ergonomically centered. And running at a different aspect ratio and resolution just illustrates that the screen is too large otherwise.

Price comes into the practicality equation, too. The bigger displays that offer high-end features tend to cost a lot. Gigabytes Aorus FV43U is on the smaller side and costs $1,100 (1,000 / AU$1,699), and our review still found it too big for up-close use. The best gaming TVs dont come cheap either.

None of this is to say you cant go for a big screen to enjoy PC games on. If youre setting up your gaming PC in the living room or plan to play at some distance, it can be a great setup. But, for traditional PC gaming at a desk, youre better off waiting for some of these premium features to eventually
make it to the gaming monitor market rather than opting for a big TV or a display acting like a monitor despite having the proportions of a TV. Welcome to TechRadars PC Gaming Week 2021 , our celebration of the greatest gaming platform on Earth. Despite the global pandemic and ongoing GPU shortages, PC gaming has never been more vibrant and exciting, and throughout the week well be reflecting this with a selection of in-depth articles, interviews and essential buying guides.



======================================================================
Link to news story: https://www.techradar.com/news/are-tv-sized-displays-actually-practical-as-pc- gaming-monitors/


--- Mystic BBS v1.12 A47 (Linux/64)
* Origin: tqwNet Technology News (1337:1/100)